For the most part, a solid show. It is not a regular part of my rotation, but I check in from time to time and it is usually worthwhile.

It’s a good podcast. Sometimes, the research is not as deep as one might hope. The host is lively, the topics mostly interesting. I’d put it in the top 20% of history pods I’ve listened to repeatedly.

I’ve been listening to this podcast since its inception, thanks to The Bowery Boys! The topics are always so interesting, the guests always so knowledgeable, and i just love how Carl packs so much information into each episode! I also find the rhythm of his voice to be very relaxing and engaging, and he has a story-telling like quality to his intro’s which I absolutely love. Thanks, Carl!! Keep up the great work!!

Great episode!

I came across this podcast by happenstance not knowing exactly what I wanted but knowing it included Edith Wharton and the time period she writes about. I typed in a few key words and this little golden nugget showed up. I decided (as I was working on a home project) to start from episode 1 and just continue on. I love this podcast. So well done and so thorough. I have recommended to friends and family. Love love LOVE! Keep them coming please! 🧡

As a huge fan of Edith Wharton, I am so glad to have found this podcast. I thoroughly enjoy Carl Raymond’s presentation style. Each episode is fascinating and well written. I have learned a great deal that has only supported my appreciation of the era.

Mr. Raymond - you must learn to phrase your interview questions to your guests better and more smoothly instead of always saying to your guests "Can you talk about..." ... this or that - it's a grammatically and conversationally poor lead-in. And you repeat it to the point of distraction, jumping and changing from topic to topic. The historical info is good, just a style point. Have you done a show on Gilded Age gentlemen's reading rooms? I used to live across the street from the one in Newport RI.

I really enjoy this podcast. It was watching the Gilded Age that first got me interested in the real life history of this time period and now I can’t get enough! Suggestion: the music during the first 7+ minutes is much too loud. It should be more of a quiet background to the story but instead it’s at the same audio level. It comes across as overpowering.

I love how you bring history to life. I’m really enjoying this podcast and have listened almost everyone. Thank you for providing it.

Fascinating! Can’t wait to go on one if Keith’s tours! Amazed to hear that you would have liked to live in Cyrus West Field’s house (was at 1 Lexington)! Field was the ancestor of my niece’s husband! Wonder if Ruffles family is connected to Ruffles Ave. in Newport Rhode Island?

I love listening to this podcast. It feels like I am invited to a group to gossip on the history of the Gilded Age as a friend. After listening to this podcast I feel life has a glint of gold in it.

This is the first podcast I’ve listened to from The Gilded Gentleman and it was terrific!! Did not know much about Wharton but with Dr Olando providing insight and details I learned so much. Will be reading The Age of Innocence in the near future and listening to future podcasts from the Gilded Gentleman in the future. Would love to take a class with Dr Olando she was fantastic!!

Well-researched and fascinating pod. I LOVED the Edith Wharton episode The Age of Innocence is one of my all time faves and listening to the historian talk about it and Edith W was so gratifying. At one point it is mentioned that EW is “no Jane Austen,” and I say THANK GOD! EW’s stories are so real, her prose, exquisite. The stark reality of her stories is wrapped in layers and you need to peel them away one by one to appreciate the complexity of the human nature that she is conveying. I appreciate her subtleties, her gorgeous descriptions. Thank you for this wonderful conversation.

I loved the very first episode I listened to, with Carla L Peterson the author of Black Gotham. It’s so nice to find a podcast that is entertaining and smart and the same time. Great work!

I’d love this podcast but please god in heaven find a synonym for iconic it is used so overly much it is quite annoying

I love this podcast. Helps me unwind from my day and calm my mind. Please continue making episodes. I especially like the Carl-only episodes.

Few podcasts exist that excite me as much as this one. While I enjoy the HBO series on gilded age New York, I get positively giddy whenever I see that a new episode of this podcast has dropped. The topics are both eclectic and well-researched. I can’t wait to hear what happens next.

I just discovered this podcast and can’t stop listening! The host is so enthusiastic and knowledgeable and I really feel transported to this glamorous time. Highly recommend.

I just started listing and can’t stop! It really takes you to a time and place… excellently researched episodes add to the experience

Was tipped off about this podcast from a Colby College friend! I have been reading my great grandmothers journals, ( she was born in 1870) who documents life in NYC.. and I love how you dig in to the images and culture of the time period. So fun and interesting! Thank you Carl!!

I enjoy everything about this show. 10/10 recommend! Thank you so much for all the time and thought you put in creating each episode.

Well researched, well written and presented in such a compelling way, these episodes are wonderful. Thank you so much.

I love this podcast and listening to Carl Raymond! His voice and presentation makes me feel as if he is speaking to me over a cuppa!

Carl is a fantastic story teller very interesting and well researched stories about New York and the people that made New York,Keep up the great podcasts Carl. JohnYonkers New York

Love this podcast - engaging , fun and informative! Carl is so knowledgeable, learn so much with every listen. Never miss it .

I adore this podcast

Many thanks for a completely surprising interview with Tracey. Where did Carl get his journalistic chops? The questioning was unblemished. Everything made sense, and the pace of the interview further our understanding. Thank you.

Great interviews with knowledgeable host and always interesting guests! Episode 44, a Gilded Age tour of NYC, is my favorite episode to date.

My new favorite is the Sweeney Todd episode with Sarah Rice. It's a satisfying in-depth look into the play and the original production which is not to be missed.

I came to the Gilded Gentleman via the Bowery Boys, and it has quickly become one of my must-listen podcasts. The Gilded Age/Belle Epoque/Edwardian Era is such a fascinating time, and Carl imbues these stories with so much flair and spirit. Each episode is informative, curious, a bit quirky, and always a great time!

I just adore this podcast. Everything about it- the detailed knowledge, your lovely voice, and the escapism it provides. I even love the theme tune! Thank you for all of your work!! Absolute perfect history show about the Gilded Age. Bravo!

A well produced and interesting history podcast! I started listening after I loooved watching The Gilded Age (HBO) . Carl does an incredible job researching and packaging topics.

I love taking a walk and listening to Carl of the gilded gentleman. It really makes my day.

Carl is wonderful. This may be my favorite episode.

Lol what is with the “affected” speech of Tucci. Embarrassing.

An awesome episode! Mr. Tucci is a wonderful storyteller! I hope the book becomes an Audiobook and reads it! Love the show

Gilded Gentleman is just a pleasure to listen to. Carl is the most fluent narrator of fascinating tales of characters and events of The Gilded Age. I listen to each episode at least twice and prize the “extras” I get from his Patreon stream.

I love the format, the information, the history, and the charm. I look forward to each new episode.

Loved this episode on Bertha Palmer. I hope more people learn about this fascinating, intelligent, wealthy woman who played a pivotal role in rebuilding Chicago after the city was destroyed by fire. Not one to remain an idle society lady she helped the poor and indigent and single handedly created Sarasota, FL. The reason I listen to this podcast is because I learn about people, places and events that are often not well known.

I Love this podcast ! Carl you are so charming and knowledgeable

I have enjoyed listening to the Podcast! It’s so well done. I’m excited for the next episodes! It’s so hard to wait for two weeks ☺️. Thank you for the awesome job your doing 💕

Delightful may seem like too limp a title to accompany a five-star review, but in this case consider it robust and apt. Carl Raymond is the perfect host: knowledgeable about and enthralled by his subject, courteous to his guests and able to give them focused appreciation, and wide-ranging in the topics he selects. If I liked tea, I would always have a cup at my side while listening. Make mine herbal, Carl, and please keep up your delightful work.

This podcast is incredible. I’m doing research for a book I’m writing and was looking for a podcast on the gilded age/ progressive era to give me some insights into the nuances of these periods. I’ve found quite a few but this one is by far my favorite. This podcast is fun, informative and so well done. Love it!

Carl is a knowledgeable and fun storyteller who brings history vividly to life!

This is a great podcast. Carl is incredibly knowledgeable about the time period, and really seems to love educating others about it. His enthusiasm comes through in every episode. Make sure to look out for him on the occasional Bowery Boys live Zoom events, too! So much fun.

I am and always have been obsessed with this time period because of the extravagance and the excess. I am intrigued with the history of it, and so glad to hear these amazing stories. One of my favorite historical podcasts.

If you love the TV show “The Guilded Age”, Edith Wharton, stories of robber barons and their world, and anything related to this fascinating bygone era, you will ADORE The Guilded Gentlemen. Carl Raymond is an outstanding writer and podcaster who brings a “gently produced” show every two weeks. My wife and I are ADDICTS!

Revisionist history podcast that refers to the “devastation” former slave owners experienced without so much as acknowledging the horrors of slavery is disgusting. Happens on multiple episodes. No thanks. Next.

I really enjoy learning about all the real people behind the HBO show. Plus all the extras!

I have been so delighted to listen to your podcast. Thank you for your hard work . I love having a cup of tea with you 💕