Love this podcast! Carmen’s predictions are hilarious and I love the banter. Keep up the amazing work. Wishing your families well.

As a long-time Grey’s fan, I love hearing the recaps of the show! It’s so entertaining to hear Carmen’s reactions to the episodes and listening to him and Kelcey banter is quite amusing. Highly recommend it for any Grey’s fans! Just remember: No Spoilies!

U guys are awesome!!! I listen to this podcast to pass time at work and it has made me laugh out loud several times....I love being reminded of my fave Grey's episodes and all the antics of my fave characters...thanks!!!

So fun to relive the series in this great podcast! Even if they’re mean to one of my favorite characters. Also, LOVE the friendship of the hosts. It’s like chatting with friends about my favorite show. Keep up the friendly banter!!

Huge fan of Greys and I just started binge watching Greys Anatomy all the way from season 1 and decided to listen to the podcast while I’m at work … love this podcast ! Thank you for being a daily entertainment!

I recently found this podcast and have been binge listening at work. I love this podcast! I love how authentic and honest the hosts are. Unpopular opinion: I love George O’Malley and always have. ❤️ I make no apologies for my George love. However, I can understand why some don’t like him. Great job and I look forward to future episodes.

Although I hate that quote from Meredith, I find it worthy enough to use to review this podcast. I don’t know how I came across this podcast, but I love that idea. I’ve been listening to it nonstop at work while I drive while I shower even till I fall asleep to the point where I have to restart that episode because I don’t know if I heard it or not. I am an avid Grey’s Anatomy fan, and I was excited to find this podcast and actually listen to it I do find myself screaming at you guys sometimes when you can’t think of a name or say something wrong, but I laugh and joke with you guys and I am going to hate when I am all caught up. Keep up the great work!!!!

I love this podcast! Listening to Kelcey and Carmen talk Grey’s (and everything else!) is like chatting with your friends! The only downside-I’m all caught up! Thank you for making this podcast so much fun!

I love everything about this podcast! The banter is amazing and I adore y'all! Thank you for making me laugh! 🙂

If you are a Greys fan this is the podcast for you! A super fun re-watch podcast! These two hosts provide a great quirky perspective on the series and dish a hilarious commentary! One host has seen the show countless times and the other must have recently moved to daylight from under a rock because he has no knowledge of the series! No spoilees here!! So grateful to have happened upon this podcast when I did and I look forward to many seasons to come!! -Brianna from Oregon

Grey’s kept coming up on my TikTok feed and I’d eventually get curious and google a plot because I was “not watching a 20 season show.” But I did! So fast! And my fiance is willing to let me infodump, but it’s nice to sit with people who love the show and hear them get mad and frustrated and all the things. So glad to have a show that feels like chatting about an obsession with friends!

👍

I absolutely love this pod. The hosts just feel like your friends and we’re all reliving this crazy show together. It’s so fun listening to someone experience it for the first time. The banter between Kelcey and Carmen is infectious. Have had many laugh out loud moments when listening. Highly recommend!

(I’m sorry it’s a 4 star 🫣) I love this podcast! The concept of having one person who’s watched Grey’s Anatomy before and one who hasn’t, is genius! I’m a first time Grey’s watcher so it’s nice. Carmen and Kelcey have great chemistry and are hilarious! I like all the little details they talk about. The only con I can see people having with this podcast is if you like structured straight about the topic podcasts. Sometimes the first 10 minutes are Kelcey and Carmen just talking about life. In the beginning I would skip the first 10 minutes lol but now I love banter between them. They really grow on you!

This podcast is absolutely wonderful! I found it in May 2023 and feel like I am part of a wonderful podcast world! Kelcey and Carmen are absolutely hilarious and have fantastic banter that makes me laugh loudly in my car! I’ve been a big grey’s friend since season 6 and have rewatched many times. I look forward to Thursdays so I can listen to the next episode! If you like Grey’s, you should listen and join the Patreon and the discord and join the fun!

I’m watching Grey’s Anatomy for the first time, and I’ve been listening faithfully to each podcast episode after watching the TV episodes. Kelcey and Carmen are the absolute best! I love their chemistry, and their insights and commentary on each GA episode are top notch! As a GA newbie, I can definitely identify with Carmen’s viewpoints, I love his predictions, and I super appreciate Kelcey’s deep knowledge of the show and her ability to keep the spoileys away! I’m currently mid-way through season two, and I’m definitely planning to watch every GA episode and listen to every GA podcast episode. You guys rock!!

I love this podcast so much! I binged the whole thing in a month and love being caught up (except now waiting on weekly updates 😂) You guys are incredible- your dynamic and banter and even just chatting about non greys stuff is amazing and I love listening. It always feels like listening to my friends chat and I feel like I gained two new amazing friends by listening to this. Keep doing what you’re doing!! Love you guys!!

I want to like this podcast - less chatter in the beginning would help - I literally had to keep fast forwarding and at 20 mins you still were not on the episode- some banter ok 20 mins too much

I absolutely love you guys!! These 2 best friends are absolutely hilarious and never fail to make me laugh I have only watched Greys 2Xs I wish I would have found the podcast during my first watch but I’m glad I found it when I did. Hearing Carmen’s predictions is GREAT

I just started listening! Ive binged yall watching the first three seasons so far. Ive seen the show countless times and have fell back into a rewatch along with ya. I was never in love with Derek and Meredith (spoily: especially after the way he treats his career against merediths time and time again to her career detriment) i do however struggle with the izzy and george judgement 😂 but i fear it is because i find myself being them… so it’s probably completely valid judgement 😂 love the strong opinions of these two while the also keep themselves open to criticism and reflection on their perspectives on things! Also love the male female friendship dynamics! Reminds me of me and my brothers and friends for sure!

As an avid Spotify user, I downloaded Apple Podcasts just to leave this review. I found this gem of a podcast after starting yet another Grey’s Anatomy rewatch, and was hooked since the very first episode. Carmen and Kelcey maintain a wonderful balance between witty banter, current events, and off the wall predictions in addition to the episode review. Watching this feels like being with your closest friends, and I’m so glad we can all be livin in Shondaland together.

I grew up watching Greys, decided to listen to this podcast during a rewatch as an adult. This podcast is like watching the show all over again for the first time! Carmen and Kelcey make you feel like you’re listening to your best friends fall in love with your favorite show. Their banter is so funny and this podcast is a great companion to the series.

I’ll admit, I hopped on board for the Miles episode, but I’m staying for the ride! I began my Grey’s Anatomy journey a few months ago, and I couldn’t imagine better hosts to geek out with. Kelsey and Carmen seem like such bright, kind, funny people. Instant comfort podcast status!

I found this podcast 3 weeks ago and I’m currently on S4E8! I’m really enjoy listening to Carmen (my fellow Scorpio!) watch Greys for the first time. I’m obsessed with Greys with at least 10 full season rewatches under my belt. I think Kelcey should have patreon guest come on for spoiler convos once a month to laugh at Carmen’s predictions. Also, I’m officially a patreon! Keep up the great work!

I LOVE THIS PODCAST! I don’t listen to many podcasts, but Carmen and Kelsey’s comedic timing and chemistry is unmatched. I’d listen to any show they do if they add to their catalog! 5* recommend to everyone!

I freakin love this podcast!!! Found it a week ago and I’m halfway through season 2. I want to slow down because I don’t want to catch up to y’all lol keep it up! Also I LOVE the predictions. I have laughed out loud, shaken my head, and for some I went hmmm very good! Love it!

Best podcast I ever heard!

Been looking for a good greys podcast for awhile now and this one definitely does the job. I is super fun to listen to and the hosts are amazing.

Two of my favorite people created a podcast about one of my favorite shows so of course I had to listen. Kelcey and I would discuss Grey’s all the time (as we are crazy and put ourselves through this show multiple times) and now it’s funny to hear Carmen’s perspective as a first time watcher. Listening to their commentary is the best and I sometimes catch myself talking back to them as if I’m part of it…which one day I hope to be a guest speaker. Keep it coming with the predictions too cause I find some hilarious. Please listen to this podcast to hear all about our favorite TGIT show!

As someone who has watched this series over and over again, it has been so great to listen to Kelcey and Carmen give their thoughts and views on each episode! I have learned so many fun facts from Kelcey about the show that I hadn’t known even after all these years of watching. I eagerly await for the Thursday drop each week to hear Carmen’s reaction to classic Greys moments and the “living in Shondaland” jingle. It’s a beautiful day to listen to this podcast!!!

Kelcey and Carmen do an excellent job recapping Greys! It’s very easy when 2 friends podcast, for the listener to feel almost on the ‘outside,’ however these two really do a great job of bringing the listener in. In fact, multiple times, I feel like I’m in the room with them part of the conversation (yes, I’ve even found myself commenting out loud multiple times). They have a great chemistry. I’ve seen the series multiple times and it’s so much fun to rewatch through Carmen’s eyes as a first time viewer. So entertaining, so captivating, I get excepted for each episode to come out every week!