We all know the typical movie review format, and this podcast doesn’t stray far from that, with a couple notable exceptions: the hosts are husband & wife and often have very different tastes in movies, and their ratings are actually pretty honest. If they don’t like a film, they’re going to let you know, in the most hilarious way possible. Sarah and James are a lot of fun to listen to, and I’m always excited for a new episode to drop.

These two have the best chemistry, which makes this podcast even better!

I’m glad Sara and James still do PS I Hate This Movie.

Blood and Chocolate, review Blood and Chocolate. I swear you will absolutely hate it

I wish it was more than monthly

Love James from STM and CIS, this show is great. Sarah and James together are just as magical as James and Jimmie 😍

This podcast is rad

Sarah and James are so funny together! I have always loved James’ other podcasts, but this one has become my new favorite. The way Sarah talks about her childhood and admits funny (sometimes embarrassing) stories are usually the best part. And the way James gets so irritated about the movies and goes on rants is hilarious. Keep making these episodes, please!

Sarah and James have the best chemistry, it’s adorable! I am thoroughly entertained on my long commute listening to these two talk about awful movies I may or may not have a soft spot for. I just discovered this podcast and hope you guys keep doing more. If I could give 10 stars, I would!!

Sarah and James play off each other so well. Whether they’re roasting a movie I love or roasting a movie I hate, I love it just the same. So happy they’re putting out new episodes again!

I listen to his other stuff too

50 Shades Darker is just what I needed to kick off this Monday, I am audibly laughing while I clean houses. So happy to have new episodes peppered in again!!

This is the only husband and wife podcast I listen to. It’s always a great time and doesn’t feel like a couple just trying to legitimize their relationship

This show is so funny and their chemistry is so good! Love! 💜

Honestly, the way you two make each other laugh is half the fun of this podcast. And what a fantastic episode on Spice World. Such a funny review on an utterly ridiculous movie that I’m afraid I lost a few brain cells watching…but at least I didn’t feel compelled to bring out a noose!

Yaaaaasssss! So happy you guys are back! My wife is a huge STM and CIS fan, but PSIHTM is the best! I’ve was legitimately concerned you all had broken up and I’m so happy to, not only hear you again, but see that your beautiful relationship is flourishing! ❤️ Amazing podcast

The return of this delightfully snarky podcast is just what I needed in 2025! Everything is dust but this is a reprieve, along with every other podcast James & Sarah do. 👩🏻‍🍳 💋

I nearly fell over when I saw there were new episodes. ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

Been re-listening to the previous episodes. Always makes me laugh. I enjoy knowing there are other people out there that tear into these types of movies. A great start already to your return with the new episode!

Michael Jackson had 133 million viewers during his Super Bowl and the Super Bowl the spice girls with Madonna and other big names not just spice girls had 114 million. No comparison

As a husband/wife team you mesh so well on this podcast. I’m not even a romantic comedy fan!

Great show! It's great to have new episodes after the long hiatus. Keep em comin, please.

Y’all are back! ❤️

Welcome back!!!!

This show is hysterical

I love all of James’s shows and this one is very good as well. I’d like to hear more even though James is probably too busy with the other shows.

So enjoyable, I listen to 99.7% true crime podcasts but I just love these movie reviews! Seeing a new episode out was a great Christmas gift

I feel inclined to watch this train wreck tonight!

I was tickled to see a new episode:) then I watched hot frosty and giggled more than I would’ve had I not listened to it first !

We are hooked on this podcast! Y’all are hilarious!

I just found you guys about a month ago and I’ve gone through all of your episodes! I was coming back to listen to some again and you’re back!!

Love this podcast - James and Sarah are hilarious. Thank you for bringing it back for the Hot Frosty Christmas special!

I am so happy for this gem!! Hopefully you are back! I miss your podcast and listen to your older episodes again and again!

I totally forgot about this podcast but seeing a new post today more than made my day .. a Christmas miracle.

What a great Christmas gift. Thanks for coming back to review this…thing.

very fun show.

I love Jimmie and James. So happy to discover this podcast also. I got my wife in and listening now also.

I was listening to old episodes of Small Town Murder when James plugged this podcast. I’m so happy I have so many episodes to binge! If the podcast was ever revived I’d be a consistent follower, they did an amazing job with their reviews. Thank you for the great binge worthy content! It’s been fun rewatching some of these movies and listening to the podcast after.

I know yall are busy with your other podcasts but PLEASE do some new episodes of this one 😭😭

This podcast is wonderful and I love everything about it. Cream of Mushroom is absolutely disgusting.

I know you’re busy James but maybe once a month You know like a horrible menstrual cycle

So funny! I hope it comes back someday :(

I wish I would have gotten into this podcast sooner and I hope it gets renewed.

Oh my god, I love this podcast. Got here via Small Town and stayed for the laughs. I just watched the twilight movie with sound off while you guys commented and it’s the best time I’ve had in a long time. For a misanthropic introvert this was like having friends over for movie night. Perfect. Chef’s kiss. You guys make more of these please! P.S you’re such an awesome couple.

You guys are the funniest

You are both hilarious and feed off of each others jokes so well!

I love the energy Sarah and James share! This podcast is all love. I really enjoy hearing their takes on movies I both love and hate. I hope they’ll be posting some new episodes soon, but even going back and listening to episodes every so often is a treat

Super love STM and Crime and Sports- particularly fond of Jimmie(yeah I know you do the work James) and now I love this too! Sarah- you’re also hilarious and lovely.

love sarah and James !

Found this podcast through Small Town Murders but Ive been bingeing this now. So funny. Such a great couple.