I adore this podcast and Chris! This has the best banter in every episode and I’m constantly feeling like I’m just hanging with friends when I listen. The jokes, the breakdown of the characters and the friendship between the hosts makes this 5 stars any and every day!

I started over from the beginning watching supernatural and found this podcast to listen along. I have enjoyed it!

It feels like hipster reviews from the early 2000s trying to make hot takes out of nothing. Not to mention the weird discomfort with the Sam and Dean’s hotness. Trying to turn it into a joke because you’re uncomfortable with sexy men is weird

Came for Supernatural, stayed for the outtakes. Great hosts, great chemistry. It’s almost not natural how great this podcast is.

Am I supposed to go dark side or something?

Great show… minus extreme political views. You’re adding to the division in this country.

Listening to this is of reminds me of how much I enjoyed Supernatural. Back when it originally aired I really loved reading (and contributing to) Television Without Pity’s forums and reading the recaps. Monster of the Week gives me of that sense of community. Discussing a show with friends, making fun of it, while still caring deeply about some fictional characters.

Just started listening but I love these guys! I feel like i’m listening to friends talk. Keep it up guys!

So, I’m listening to this podcast in tandem with another Supernatural podcast called Carrying Wayward and while this podcast is fun, the other is way more insightful. I do enjoy this podcast although the hosts frustrate me because they’re biased towards Dean. I get that Sam is flawed but so is Dean and they often overlook some of Dean’s flaws when they don’t afford the same thing to Sam. That’s why I give this podcast a four instead of a five. The hosts are great. Their banter is fun.

I’m a new listener, it’s been over a year since the series ended. At the time of this review they have just finished rewatching S2. This podcast is great because it does walk us through each episode (some in more detail than others), and the enthusiasm these guys have for SPN is palpable. I miss the show and this is a good way to get a little fix. Looking forward to hearing the rest of the episodes!

I listen to a few Supernatural podcasts and this is the best one. I'm on Season 7 of the rewatch. Chris and Jeremy are funny and insightful. Love the outakes too! I may actually be able to rewatch the series finale, maybe.

I’m years late watching Supernatural but loving it. I’ve watched 7 seasons in 7 weeks and this podcast is a fun way to close out the episodes. Chris and Jeremy are really funny.

These idjits have put together my absolute favorite podcast to date. They stay on topic with some hilarious side-bars and anecdotes that will have you seeing this show in a light that you wouldn’t have imagined before. Great commentary, inside jokes and hunks abound in this fantastic series. Thanks for the laughs, fellas

Love this podcast and Chris and Jeremy

I’ve listened to a few supernatural podcasts and this one is the best, hunkiest off all. Thanks Chris and Jeremy for the laughs. Have a hunky Happy Birthday Jeremy.

Everything to Guppy is JUST like monster of the week, but worse. The two hosts (Larry Butterfolds and Bill Huggs) don’t talk about or even stay the topic very long and digress into weird perversion immediately, where as MOTW stays on topic for the duration then has a separate segment for their goofs and personal dramas. Both feature men trying to establish personal connections via disposable entertainment, so if you’re horny for that, strap in. 4/5 stars.

Oh my god I CANNOT stop laughing at Big Kick Sam as I listen to you guys talk about season 8. I have almost woken my family several times with the volume of my straight up CACKLING at yall. This podcast is AMAZING and it makes my day every time I listen to it! Keep doin good work yall.

Good laughs, great commentary, and just two nice dudes with awesome podcast voices. 10/10 highly recommend.

I almost fell off my treadmill laughing at episode 118’s discourse on that one weekend with Papa W. All the thumbs are up.

On episode 34 and I am all about this podcast. Even at the rate I’m going through episodes (it’s difficult pausing even to write this), I’m unfortunately not going to catch up but crazy glad it’s still going. I was recommended another Supernatural podcast, but I could not get into it at all, and thought to myself, “there’s got to be a better one” because there’s so much I love about this show…then I stumbled upon this awesomeness. It’s so clear these guys do this from a place of love, even when calling out ridiculous/problematic writing, and it just fills me with joy. Equal parts insightful and hilarious, crazy grateful for this and after I finish, will definitely check out more from these two.

Lately, just leaving a star rating on Apple Podcasts doesn’t do anything because the star rating doesn’t stay. It goes away after a while and I don’t think my rating is actually being counted. So, I’m hoping that actually leaving a written review will keep it in place. So, anyway, I just started this podcast a couple weeks ago, and I’m only on season 7 (in the podcast, not the show). SPN is my favorite show ever, and I went searching for a podcast about it instead of simply rewatching it for the fiftieth time. Thanks for the entertainment!

This podcast is my favorite podcast I’ve ever listened to and I’ve listened to a lot of podcasts the hosts are hilariously amazingly inappropriate but their friendship is so weird Stephen was a character as well and the way they keep bringing up “What am I supposed to go dark side or something” and Big Kicks Sam everything about this podcast is funny I really would subscribe to Patreon if I had an account so writing a review is the second best thing 🥧🥧🥧🥧 so have some pie Chris and Jeremy and thank you for helping me get through the quarantine and hope y’all are well

I love supernatural and I do recommend this podcast. There is one thing I hate though. Jeremy mispronounces sooo many things and it is very frustrating. Other than that it’s worth a listen.

This podcast has rescued me from boredom and apathy too many times to number. NSFW - because I’ve nearly pulled a muscle trying not to laugh out loud in my quiet cubicle. Warning: binging this podcast may cause random fits of giggles (and probably brain damage #worthit)

I’m only up to the guys watching season 4, but I’m thoroughly enjoying listening to them!

I can’t stop listening to these guys, they are hilarious! I have a long commute to work and this is the perfect podcast to listen to. I’m a huge SPN fan and have watched the episodes more times than I can count but I love hearing other people’s views and opinions and Chris and Jeremy always have something inquisitive and insightful to say. I also just love that they actually like SPN and aren’t just here to make fun. Definitely awesome listening to 2 dudes talk about 2 dudes. 10/10 recommend 👍

I was in desperate need for spn content post-finale and boy howdy was it a treat to find over 200 episodes of this podcast going through every ep of the show while I'm in the middle of my own rewatch. I have put it on every day while working and it's just gotten more fun the further they get into the show. They are super funny, have good insights, great opinions. Definitely recommend!

I started listening to y’all around season 6 as I restarted Supernatural and don’t listen to every episode BUT I often find your episodes hilarious. I generally listen while working out and often break a plank or have to restart a set because I can’t control my laughter. I especially look forward to your take on the bad episodes because your jokes redeem the show for me. I would recommend your podcast to any Supernatural fan!

I’m super behind in the show and am using your pod to help catch me up. Y’all are laugh out loud funny, and make my work day SO much more enjoyable. Keep up the AMAZING work

Chris and Jeremy have fostered a wonderful community of Supernatural fans. Their approach to ensuring everyone feels safe and welcome is admirable and something all communities should emulate. Also they scream about nutting blud or whatever, it rocks.

Don’t waste your time. Low quality audio, no insight into the content, and the community is nothing but cliques. There are ten million better shows hosted by better people.

Chris and Jeremy really love the show and are funny as hell. If you love supernatural you will love this podcast.

Love the laugh out loud humor and insight these guys bring to their analysis. It’s so much fun to hear fellow fans embrace the great and the not so great moments of this amazing show. Thank you. Keep up the good work!

WHAT AM I SUPPOSED TO GO DARKSIDE I’m a little late to the game on this one and am not sure they are putting out episodes anymore but I LOVE IT. I have always been obsessed with Supernatural and I found this podcast during quarantine when they released HALF OF THE LAST SEASON and I was infuriated. This podcast helped supplement my great need for Hunks in my life and allowed me to then rewatch the whole show while waiting for new episodes to be released. I recommend this podcast to ANYONE who is a Supernatural fan, it is absolutely amazing and super entertaining. Gives you a great insight and breakdown into what Supernatural is all about, the good, the bad and the ugly and don’t forget the Hunt, Marry, Kill. I hope these boys considered putting out some new episodes with season 15. All the love.

This is a great podcast - both Jeremy and Chris are really funny and play off each other so well! There are plenty of laugh out loud moments and their love for Supernatural really shines through! I would recommend this over any other Supernatural podcast out there.

A great great podcast. The hosts are so good I listen to them talk about video games which I have absolutely no interest in

This podcast is really great. I’ve been binging it for about a week and have already made it to season 7, no complaints. It’s fun listening to two straight guys discuss this show about hunky men with absolutely no shame. I really enjoy the outtakes at the end of each episode also. It feels like I genuinely know Jeremy and Chris. Also, their voices don’t annoy the crap out of me, which is a real problem with a lot of podcasts.

Supernatural and the podcast make the work days a lot better! Awesome, you guys are awesome! 😎

I found this by accident and I started to listen to the miscellaneous ones first and I spent the first hour laughing my ass off. I love this and I can’t wait to hear more in the future. These two are great and they play off each other well. I enjoy how they approach each episode.

Okay I’d give this podcast a 5/10 review because okay let me tell you a story so In March this year I was listening to this awesome YouTuber YouTube channel name Gotta Go Fast btw don’t sub to his channel you guys may have seen yesterday’s video of. Sonic and Shadow playing. Portal 2 Shadow said subscribe to. Sonic anyway not the point I got off topic so anyway in March Sonic released a video called Tails isn’t an artist Sonic Tails and Shadow play Scribb.io and what happened in the video was Shadow threatened to kill. Sonic and tails which that hurt me a little but at the end of the video when Sonic and Tails mentioned Shadow lost at the game Shadow shouted I’m done! and left now that made me mad like really mad guys I would recommend not subscribing to Emerld Masters Emerld Masters was the voice of Shadow in that Scribble.io video and I’m so mad at Shadow now I’m not showing hate to the channel I’m just mad at shadow in general seriously guys don’t subscribe to Emerld Masters. Guys Subscribe to Tails and Sonic Pals and Gotta Go Fast thank you

I don’t know how long ago I started listening, but I am only on season 7!!! I basically listen to this podcast every day. So far, I haven’t had to watch any episodes because I’ve watched them so many times that I actually remember it all. But I think we are coming up on some seasons I’ve only seen once. Probably around season 10. It’s so funny. These guys are pretty ridiculous, and I really love it. I don’t know what most of their video game references mean, but it’s all good. Oh, and I found it because of my MFM/Supernatural FB group, the Hunterinos. Whaaaa? SSDGM

I am a 57 year old grandmother of soon to be 17 and a diehard SPN fan. I’ve just recently found your podcast and just started your season 3 reviews. You guys are very entertaining and I enjoy listening to your reviews. Some of my grands enjoy watching the show with me too. I can’t let them listen to your show though, it’s a little more than their young ears need. Thanks for keeping me entertained during the hours at work I can actually listen!

Are you sad you can’t watch Supernatural at work? Well, pop in some headphones and dig into this podcast while pretending to work. The hosts give a great recap of the episodes, add fun facts from Dads journal, and overall cause you to think a bit more about the episodes.

I blame this podcast.

This is the Supernatural podcast I never knew I needed. This is the best podcast to listen to as I rewatch my two favorite CW hunks. Thank you for the laughs and weirds glances I get from my co-workers from laughing outloud.

I am listening to this podcast as I’m watching supernatural for the first time, it always manages to make me smile even through the worst parts of my depression.

Thank you for speeding up my boring work days. It’s been hard not to laugh at my desk!

i work a data entry job where i get to listen to podcasts all day long, and for the last few weeks i've been marathoning motw eight hours a day, every work day. i'm currently up to the season seven episodes, and the hardest part has been not laughing out loud in my quiet workplace. it's all the fun of a full spn rewatch, except i can do it at work! thanks for this, guys! (thanks especially to chris mosher, who does a pretty good job of defending my personal favorite hunk, sam, which nobody but me *ever* seems to do!)

Love this podcast and Chris and Jeremy’s great banter. I use the word hunks a lot now.

I started listening to you guys right after my SPNmarathon2019 (14 seasons and all, took me weeks lol). I don’t really have a SPN buddy who watches with me, so it’s really great to hear other people watching and discussing about the these hunks lol. Carry on!