Totally kidding. You have done awesome on this! I will listen until someone is in jail for this. What a crazy story!! All my love to this family!

Got bored

I am a father of eight children four girls four boys. I have experienced every kind of emotion listening to this podcast. I have to commend the Coleman family for remaining steadfast and seeking only justice and not revenge. May PEACE come to you !!

Terrible, no evidence but conflicting 31 year old eye witness reports and a polygraph. Do better for the victim. RIP.

Amazing host! He has a gift for story telling and talent of capturing a listener.

While the story is compelling, most of the focus is on 30+ year old memories which are unreliable at best. The 30 year old memories of some witnesses are then “validated” by polygraph tests which are not widely admissible in courts due to general concerns about polygraph accuracy. While memories may still provide investigative value, the issues and limitations of the memories and polygraph tests are barely discussed in the series giving all of this the flavor of poor and sensationalized journalism. I got tired of suspending my disbelief in the accuracy of witnesses statements.

Such a great podcast! Sean is a gifted storyteller. His investigation skills, and his ability to get people to talk to him is incredible. I was so interested in the story the entire time.

This is a really well done podcast. Interesting case, a passionate host who I think is more ethical and self-reflective than most. My only issue, is that it really doesnt address how unreliable memory and eye-witness testimony is. I wish they had followed up with Markie’s wife… maybe they made a greater effort to verify accounts with documents and other interviews, but the interviews get old - memory is unreliable. But again, far above the quality of most pods. Particularly true crime serials.

Best podcast ever

You have done all cold case victims families proud! If not for your take over so to speak when the torch was passed then there would be no look into this case! Thanks for your due diligence! RIP Rhonda! Keep up the good work Sean and congratulations to a new dad! Judith

It’s impossible to listen to this without one hand on your phone volume control. Erratic audio levels make this impossible to listen

I hope justice will be brought for Rhonda, her parents and friends 🫶🏻

Sean is an amazing story teller! I listen to this whole podcast in two days!! I have listen to Sean’s other podcast and they were just as great!! Can’t wait for more!

Having grown up with Rhonda and loving Milton & Gayle so much, listening to this pod cast was very difficult. I mean I lived it back then and I personally know almost everyone speaking with you in this. Rhonda was found on my 14th birthday, it’s a day I’ll never forget. From the bottom of my heart, thank YOU for bringing light to Rhonda’s case. Thank YOU for keeping on when so many others have stopped. Thank YOU for caring! Thank YOU for being a part of bringing justice for her (it WILL happen) and all of those that love her!!

He does what the cops should have done. He’s turns over stones and made people nervous. Someone will eventually slip up and tell who did this!

When we know the results of the fingernail clippings!?

This tru crime series was my first ever Podcast and it kept us on the edge of our seats the whole time. My husband and I listened to it almost non stop on our car trip to the mountains last year all the way there and all the way back. It’s so descriptive and just like watching a Netflix series. It’s fun to talk with others about who we think are main suspects. I’m forever hooked on podcasts now! Thank you for your work on this series and with it being a true story thank you for trying to bring closure to this family.

Sadly a great podcast done well but bless Rhonda’s family for still not having answers in her death !

Listening to Rhonda’s story and the difficulties that the Colemans have endured to find out who murdered their only child got me hooked. This podcast has helped the family more over the last few years than they had from the start. This one has lead me to listen to Sean’s other podcasts, and hoping that new episodes will come along in the future for Rhonda’s case!

I’ve heard about this case my whole life. It took place when I was a child, and just one county over. Sean did an awesome job of creating this podcast. I’ve tried to listen to other podcasts, but Fox Hunter is still the best and easiest to listen to.

No I love foxes 0 star

In the many crime podcasts I have listened to, I have never heard anything good about the GBI. They seem to be crooked and disinterested in solving crimes.

I lived in a bordering county for a few years. When I was 17 I went to an older guy in his twenties to buy some pot, he took me way out in the country to his brothers house, when we arrived his brother said he had a delivery coming. Soon a sheriffs car pulled in the driveway with the delivery, in uniform. If that wasn’t scary enough, the cop said he found another dead **racial slur** in the woods. He said he left him there, “no one’s reported missing so I’m not messing with that”. Everyone laughed. That was 1979. We moved out of GA soon after, thank god.

Sean is one of the best investigative reporters out there. I was on the edge of my seat for half this season. I am so hoping for justice for the Coleman’s and other victim’s families that have endured the same miscarriage of justice. Great job, Sean, for bringing light to this case in such an authentic way.

Unless you want to hear 10 minute description of EVERYTHING in the town, the town's hisotry, etc. SO MUCH unnecessary detail the series could've been three episodes shorter if he would just get to the point.

Very well done, heartbreaking. I’ve really liked everything I’ve listened to so far by Sean Kipe, he seems to really care about the stories he’s telling and about the people involved. I hope one day the Colemans get justice for their daughter.

Incredible podcast.

This is a very sad murder of a lovely young woman. The host did a deep investigation but his voice is so annoying like he is talking to 12 year old children!! It’s not normal and injects way to much unnecessary details!! It’s also clear that the John person should have been arrested and prosecuted!!! I wish the host would talk more like an adult and be more authentic!!

What a heartbreaking story and I hope the Coleman’s get an answer about the DNA results.

Way too much reliance on polygraph results. When the actual inventor of the polygraph machine has gone on record stating that the machine is nothing but smoke and mirrors it says a lot. Remember there’s a reason why polygraph results are inadmissible in a court of law.

Incredible work by Sean. The way he reports and presents is so engaging. It’s clear he very talented! Looking forward to more by him!

Loved the way Sean handled the interviews, how respectful he was even to potential suspects, and how he stressed the importance of getting all the facts before making a judgment. A little annoyed that it’s still unsolved and I didn’t know before starting, but that’s my own fault! Great, engrossing podcast. Keeping updated on the case, hoping Gayle and Melvin get answers.

I know there are always going to be haters, but I don’t understand the negative reviews. I think the interviews are professional, the reporting is solid, and the respect for the missing girl’s memory and family exceeded my expectations. I cannot wait until this case is solved!

Unfortunately, all of Sean’s Imperative Podcasts leave the same unsatisfactory feeling. None of his podcasts provide any resolution for victims or listeners. The only I am learning from all of his podcasts is that I hope “GBI” or any agency in Georgia will ever be responsible to solve something for anyone close to me. I’m trying to keep some hope that other law enforcement agencies around the US can be more efficient, forthcoming, and trustworthy. If not, I fear for my kids and my remaining years. 😭🤷🏼‍♂️😢🤦‍♂️😭

Passing a polygraph just means you believe what you’re saying or you’re really good at lying. It doesn’t mean what you’re saying is true.

I just listened to this entire Podcast. I pray the people involved and responsible come forward. If not, the DNA will force them too. I’m sick over the GBI dropping the preverbal ball. I pray they have now picked it back up. I know you have made a difference and I look forward to hearing this case is solved. Thank You!

Excellent research. Excellent writing and delivery. This is an, all around, awesome piece of work. This man is making a difference in the lives of these victim’s families and is bringing awareness to the much needed reform in the criminal justice system. I look forward to his future projects!

What an incredible job with this investigation and presentation! The corruption in Georgia seems to be the devils work in perpetuity. Sean Kipe really knows how to deliver the facts eloquently. I’m praying his persistence and tenacity on this case will help bring justice for Rhonda and peace to her sweet family. I’ll be following this case to the finish line. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

Amazing! Hoping this podcast keeps bringing dark to light!

All of the podcasts that I have listened to have been great. This one hit me more than the others, I feel so sorry for Rhonda’s family after all of these years. I can’t stop listening, I am addicted.

All three of his shows have been absolutely enthralling. A wonderful storyteller, and keeps you on the edge of your seat until the last episode. beautifully written and captivating. I cannot hype his work enough. And as a fellow Georgia-native, the “localness” of all of them is pretty cool, too. Can’t wait to hear more from him!

I really want justice for Rhonda! This family deserves a new investigation and justice.

Way too drawn out. Basically a bunch of he said/she said that goes absolutely nowhere.

Don’t waste your time. This story is dragged out over too many episodes and goes nowhere with way too many commercials

With all things Sean Kipe. This story is compelling and informative, and it is even a little reminiscent of the small town feel from In The Red Clay- another must listen.

I can never listen to any of your podcasts anymore!!!!!! Because there is going to be anything better than this one here this podcast was by far the best I have ever herd hands down!!!!!!!!!!!

Started off on the right foot then became very choppy and hard to follow. Narrator began throwing suspecting people which he believed to be the culprit without any hard evidence. Way too many interviews to follow. This was really all over the place and *SPOILER ALERT******* still a cold case which seemed like a waste of time after thirteen episodes.

Very well put together podcast — good pacing, good research. The only negative from my POV is how much the host insinuates himself into the story. The focus should stay on the victim and her family.

Great (in an oxymoron kinda way) podcast. Concise, easy to listen/follow reporting. The story is engaging but most of all I love the true crime podcasts like this one that fill multiple roles. A heartbreaking story that keeps you wanting more information & a mode of awareness for legal/community action and reform that is more importantly an AMAZING outcome for this type of platform. In full support of this work! Will be following indefinitely for any updates or future calls to arms for this family. Thank you for the dedication and reporting. Will be recommending to all my people!

Entertaining and informative