If I could create a spirit animal out of Johnny and Tyler, it would embody exactly the perfect mixture of fun, intelligent, well informed and well researched topics that touch topics relevant today, but also the weird and wild historical facts. Fun fact for me was recently when I listen to your Connie converse while delivering packages to the ungrateful lazy soul of this planet. I was pleasantly surprised to hear them. I’m talking about a location. Literally 10 minutes from where I used to live. They are iconic, and the reason I smile. Plus, I love to tell my friends about some of the tales such as the woman that married to ghost and the guy that cut his own a hem off on mushrooms… Whatever greater being there is out there for you and don’t worry, I will pay the pet tax via email to share a photo of our newest nine week old addition to our family Francesca Louise pickle Germain Sargent you can say the whole name if you want to as known as coming out of my mouth because she’s being annoying, she’s cute! Look forward to many many many more episodes to come and sharing all the fabulous that you offer. Thank you so much for everything you do spooky - Samantha in my

First off, I would be overjoyed if you read this review hint, hint, hint. And feel free to use my name. I love this podcast! Johnny and Tyler have gotten me through the most horrific couple of years of my life. Just after the pandemic, my husband of 32 years, walked out on me. For the last three years, he has not spoken a word to me and would only communicate through text messaging. I found very little to bring me joy. But Johnny and Tyler never cease to make me smile and to bring me a hearty laugh when nothing else could. Their love for each other and the Animal Kingdom truly instilled my faith in humanity. Thank you, thank you, thank you for being my friends during the darkest time of my life. I love you guys as though I know you. You deserve nothing but the best the world has to offer. And I hope you get nothing but five star ratings from now until eternity. Much love to your little wildlife kingdom. Those are some lucky critters to have you guys as daddies. XOXO. And by the way, my ex-husband has suffered a life-threatening illness, and no one was there to support him, including his recent girlfriend. But I stepped up and have shown him what forgiveness looks like. We are developing a delicate friendship, which more importantly than anything, is giving our only daughter, who lives overseas, some peace of mind. Again, boys, thank you for reminding me what Love looks like. Emily from New York

Love , love love this amazing Canadian duo! They are both so good at being super inclusive, amazing story tellers. Tyler's cute giggle makes me laugh every time. Every time I listen I speak out loud, " god I love these guys!" Every story is so well told and the SGB episodes help to offset some of the more serious and heavy main episodes. I absolutely adore you two and can't wait to hear more. Low you....kisses! XO

Anytime podcasts come up in casual conversation I start shouting until whoever I’m talking to starts listening to That’s Spooky. I can’t say enough about Johnny and Tyler’s charisma and chemistry. Plus Tyler and I share a spooky birthday so obvi we’re kindred spirits. Love these two and kissy kisses 💋

Look at moi ploise; I’ve got one word for you… listen to this pod! The delightful voices and banter of Tyler and Johnny are like a soothing balm to a frazzled brain. Their choice of content is gorgeously curated and their low stakes advice always hits (@ Johnny, I just got the chrome dipped nails and they are hitting!) Most of all, these gorgeous guys make every episode so mindful, so demure (so cutesie) with their inclusive and thoughtful approaches to how they address everyone and everything in their podcast and still make it a laugh riot. I always feel better after listening to them. This podcastussy is on fire, babes!

Johnny and Tyler make my queer black heart so happy. Their banter and chemistry? Delicious. Their covering of cases? Very demure, very mindful. As a fat positive, creative, goth they really hit all the notes for me— like Mariah Carey in a Christmas Special.

You guys are the best and I love the content you create so much but, I could honestly listen to you just talk about drag race! Johnny and Tyler 5ever😘

Hey- thanks for the long episodes of very spooky content. Your voices are relaxing to listen to and I laughed so much- yer fun and great and I thank you!

I discovered That’s Spooky from Morbid and it quickly became one of my favorites. Combining two of my favorite things; Drag Race & True Crime 🤍 I love that they cover haunts, Lore, cryptids, and everything in between. I’m a lash artist and every Friday I have a client we listen to the latest SGB episode. It’s my favorite day of the week! Love you guys! Kissy Kisses 😘😘😘😘😘

They are rad and I love them.

I love these queens. I’ve been vaccinating myself against spooky and scary things for years and you have been a huge part of that. When I’m in a scary situation I think of Tyler’s laugh and it’s no longer scary. Love you!!

I’ve been laughing so hard while listening and driving that other motorists probably think I am the subject of the next episode. But I am owning it. Nothing says “stable individual” like ugly laughing alone in your car about horrible crimes. I love their chemistry and humor. Just a fair warning: listening while operating heavy machinery may result in concerned citizens calling authorities. But trust me it’s worth the potential cavity search. *Bisous*

I’ve been having a crappy day today and decided I needed a good laugh. Immediately thought to listen To this podcast. Tyler and Johnny are so funny. Love the content and their banter. Truly love tuning in! Love, Kim

I was very pleasantly surprised when I listened to this podcast to discover not only true crime and good spooky stories, but lots of talk about RuPaul‘s Drag Race! It’s hard to find the intersection of my interests in spookiness and drag. I love the banter. These two help brighten my day!

I was hooked by the first episode! Such a fun time and hilarious banter! Big love for these two!!

They have amazing banter and enjoy listening to them all the time. Their research is amazing and not just the first few articles you could google. As one who’s had to write more research papers than I’d like to think about, reputable sources and in depth research is always appreciated. Bonus points, they do it themselves……..Anyway…my teenager now enjoys listening to them and has told me, “You’ve been listening to them so much they’ve kinda grown on me. I actually kinda like them.”

I quote you guys on a near daily basis, you guys crack me up! Also, I have absolutely no idea how Tyler made it through the poem at the end of SGB #134 without dying! I had literal tears. Keep doing what you guys do! 🖤

Thanks for your podcast these two wonderful hosts make me laugh cry etc. their banter among with the topics are the pinnacle of fantastic fabulous podcasting keep doing what you’re doing...which is being awesome!

Whenever I’m asked what my favorite podcast is, That’s Spooky is my answer! I love these gays, they make my weekly cooking, walks, and cleaning, so much more fun. Love from Albania!

I don’t know if it makes a difference that I give you a five star rating like every episode but I’m gonna try that and see if it’s noticeable my name is Fawn she/her. I love your guts.

I found this podcast last summer when I was doing a 52 mile Pride Ride to raise money for The Trevor Project. It quickly became one of my favorite podcasts and entered my weekly rotation. I also have been listening to old episodes. Besides the awesome stories you share, I love how you support and stand up for everyone in the LGBTQ+ community. I am a Mama Bear (look up real mama bears online) and an ally. I also became a crisis counselor for The Trevor Project this year and spend 3 hours a week supporting the LGBTQ+community. Your relationship and success gives me hope for the youth I support every week. Thank you for being YOU. Thank you for being allies for others. Thank you for sharing your stories and your humor every week. Thank you!

This is one of my very favorite podcasts. I love their dynamic and their humor so much! Thank you both for bringing the joy to your podcast, it is much needed!

My co-worker introduced me to your show, and I am so grateful. We are in public accounting and especially this time of year are working so much. It can be depressing. However, the two of you brighten my day every time I listen, and you somehow juxtapose light-heartedness with morbid, shocking, and sometimes gross news. It’s amazing. Keep up the fantastic work and stay awesome.

These guys are educational and hilarious. I love the spooky stuff of course.

This podcast is the only reason I ever remember to moisturize my neck. 5 stars.

5 stunning beautiful stars to this wondrous show. I cannot describe the joy you two bring into my day while listening.. you’re both so kind, talented, intelligent, hilarious, and thoughtful in how you tell stories, and I appreciate all the work you put into it. Thank you!

Such a great podcast I love the banter and comedy while still keeping it respectful. Learned about them from the Morbid podcast and they quickly became a favorite keep up the great work

I love you guys! You’ve become my favorite podcast!!

I love this show and was listening to it daily and am utterly confused as to why the two of you wouldn’t be talking about the genocide happening to the Palestinians. It’s a huge let down to a lot of people who take comfort in listening to you. Don’t know if I’ll ever really follow the show like I used to.

These two are the best part of my morning! They’re beautiful, they’re perfect, they look like Linda Evangelista! They cover everything from true crime to aliens in the most tasteful, fun way. They’ll have you thinking, and they’ll have you laughing!

This is my comfort podcast I listen to them whenever I’m having rough morning or day in general they always bring a smile to my face. When my coworkers ask me what’s making me laugh it’s hard to explain that it’s a paranormal/true crime podcast lol. Anyways I’ve recommended this podcast to at least 10 people and I’ll continue to do so because they are the best. 🖤🖤🖤

Initially introduced to this duo via the first crossover with Ash and Alaina’s Morbid, I have decided that Tyler and Johnny can do no wrong in my book. Their podcast has provided me endless hours of entertainment while working, distance running, and generally sloth-ing around my home. From haunted dolls to drag race to my favorite spooky stories, I adore you both to the moon and back. While I already have a lot of gay in my life (Guncles and gay besties) these two hold a special spot in my f*g hag heart. Great story telling and banter are a reflection of their sweet love story. Keep it coming boys, I’ll be faithfully listening. 🤍

That’s Spooky is my very favorite podcast. Johnny and Tyler are hilarious and so entertaining! I don’t know how I’d get through my day without them (or get anything done)…love them!!

I wanted some relatively light spooky content from funny hosts and that is EXACTLY what this is. Johnny & Tyler’s banter is endearing. They do some true crime but in a respectful victim oriented manner. They are great and as long as they make this pod, I will listen. Highly recommend

Johnny and Tyler are the most and I love tuning in every week! Thank you for the spooky content. I desperately want to join the secret society. Love and kisses 💋💋💋💋from Spooky MI your downstairs neighbor. 💙🖤

LOVE this podcast and the two hosts. Brilliant. I am hooked!

This is my favorite podcast to listen to after having an edible and washing dishes. Whilst listening and washing dishes today, I realized why this is my favorite podcast. Of course I love Johnny and Tyler (thanks for getting me into Drag Race!) and I love spooky stories. But what I love about their story telling is that, unlike other spooky podcasts, they don’t try to convince you that something supernatural occurred. They give the facts and include all the theories and opinions. There’s almost always a reasonable explanation to solve the mystery. It’s like learning how a magic trick is done. Kissy Kisses! 😘

100/10! Did I think that all things spooky could be cute and wholesome?!? I did not! Until this wonderful podcast stumbled into my life life a like a sweet, quirky drunk gurl that you meet in the bathroom, and then for those 5 minutes you are BFFs. However, I don’t just want 5 minutes- Oh no… I want the calm and sultry voices of Johnny and Tyler until the to end of TIME! J&T, yes you!!! Thank you for all you do. Your podcast is my number 1 and makes my heart flutter everyone time a new episode is blessed to the world. It’s the most delichas, and refreching thing out there. Medicine to my ear holes baby. She’s ICONIQUE! Kissy kisses. Love, Jasmine (from California, USA)

I listen to these babes on Wondery but im not able to leave a review.. so of course I have to come here 🩶 Tyler and Johnny help me stay the weirdo neighbor that’s laughing to herself while doing yard work, in what looks like complete silence. I love y’all so much and I love following along as you grow as people and a podcast! Thank you for all the cackles and laugh-snorts!

I originally come here just to check you guys out bc of Ash & Alaina talking about you guys fairly often & now i’m almost entirely caught up with every episode you guys have posted! you guys are so funny to listen to & i can’t wait to see you guys continue to grow !! byeeeeeee!

I love Johnny and Tyler!! Definitely one of my favorite podcasts & I always remember their anniversary because it’s on my Birthday 💕 Keep up the amazing work love you both kissy kisses for Fleetwood & Daphne

I love these dudes. They never fail to make me laugh and smile. They have a great variety of topics from paranormal to true crime to urban legend to quirky fun. Get into it! Kissy kisses, Johnny & Tyler!

This podcast is like a salad from Taco Bell- weird, funny, mixed up, strange, unusual, sensual, horrific (in the best way) and exactly what you want and need. TRUST ME. 🌮🎉

You ever feel like you just don’t belong? Like the whole world is loosing its mind!??! Thank god for my moment of sanity!! It’s more than a podcast! Thank you Johnny and Tyler 💚🖤🐈

My favorite way to start my day. Anyone leaving hateful reviews obviously no taste. Great combo of comedy, spooky, true crime, and empathy for the victims. Love your banter, don’t change a thing.

My cousin recently sent your podcast my way, and let me tell you, instantly obsessed!! Tyler and Johnny bring on the spooky every week, as well as the humor!! My new favorite quote, “Feed two birds with one scone”!! Absolutely hilarious!! Thanks so much for being some amazing spooky queens!!! XOXO

My sister recommended this podcast to me and I love it! I’m almost caught up with the episode list and I’ve enjoyed every minute of it. Johnny and Tyler really have a talent for digging deep into the nostalgia of 90’s-2000’s pop culture, I hadn’t thought about Mob Wives or Megan Wants a Millionaire since the shows originally aired. I love you both, keep up the spooky work!

Recently started listening and immediately started binging! Obsessed 🫶

Tyler and Johnny are the absolute best. They are exceptional at telling the dark and spooky stories we all love while remaining thoughtful, compassionate, and sensitive. They are my new besties. It might not be consensual…

i have only been listening to this podcast for about 2 months but… i absolutely love this podcast! plus i was born in october so the spooky season is all year round! they make me laugh while i’m at work or whenever i listen to them! i love Johnny and Tyler